June 04, 2004
Passing Judgement
I should note that Mustafa Hirji's post has mostly been filled with a tactical evaluation of Harper and his Reformatories. The horse-race aspect of this is, I suppose, fun, and I think it's OK to indulge in this kind of analysis once in a while. But ultimately it is not possible to separate the ideological components and moral evaluations from the analysis of political tactics, and I think that some of these things should be kept up front.
Mustafa Hirji's post, fortunately, also made the connection that it is the overall tactics of the party that matter as well. And likewise, moral/ideological evaluation of Harper's politics should also be tempered with a knowledge of what the candidates for the party that backs him also intend to do. His "compromises" with the electorate cannot be seen in a vacuum; the ideological flag is often carried by someone else, and it will almost certainly appear once the "lobsters are in the pot," as a certain former Québec politician once said.
Harper's and his party's perspective on economic relations with the US as well as overall ideological alignment with certain US political trends give them a clear guide as to how to act, regardless of what Harper may or may not have said. They would have taken us to Iraq. They would certainly more align us with the War on Terra.
And so this is worth noting in the post:
Unlike Stockwell Day, Harper hasn't hidden his true stripes; he's just agreed to compromise. He won't try to do everything he wants, the old Progressive Conservatives aren't getting everything they want either, and we voters won't get everything we want. Harper is putting forward a compromise, he hopes, we can all agree with. And by being up front about this, the Liberals are having a hard time convincing the media he has flip flopped.
It should be remembered that this only holds true during election time. (There's no reason to think that the Liberals won't go down a similar road as the Reformatories if they win another term, though, but it's possible that they would do it slowly, with much sighing.) It should also be remembered that while strategy and tactics are fun, you also need to pass judgement.
Archive URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/archives/individual/2004/06/04/Mandos_passing_judgement_117.html
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/88
