April 20, 2005

More election videos, deconstructed

Secretary of Snark (email) at 08:42 AM

Over the past several months, I've been posted in the UK as Points of Information's foreign correspondent. The work is adequate, as long as I remember not to mix up the words "pants" and "trousers".

So, while election fever is just ramping up in Canada, it's already in full swing here, with the upcoming May 5th General Election. Election adverts are everywhere. Paul Wells deconstructed one of Labour's early broadcasts of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, where the two politicos were just a little too chummy. Now, other political parties are getting into the spirit of election ads.

I watched the most recent ad in a movie theatre. That was a bizzare place to watch a political ad. Here we are, sitting down with our popcorn, ready to watch Miss Congeniality 2, when Tony Blair's gigantic mug appears on-screen. Ick. Talk about spoiling the moment. It is apparently an attack ad produced by the Conservative Party.

The Ad

The ad is available at the Conservatives' website (scroll to "latest videos").

smirky grinWe see Mr. Blair repeating the phrase, "Enough of talking," over and over and over again. Mr. Blair then declares, "It is time now... to do." We then see the Conservatives' slogan, "Are you thinking what we're thinking?"

(You mean, am I thinking that you are all overly-pessimistic? Well, yes, yes I am.)

Anyway, we then have a montage of Blair faces in red, black, and white, with quite a few grins, and a couple of smirks. A montage of Labour quotations, and newspaper rebuttals, subsequently appears. For example, we see a Labour quotation of, "Immigration rules will remain clear, firm, and fair," followed by a newspaper headline describing, "NEW ASYLUM FIASCO". There are similar montages for education, taxes, crime, and health care.

Footage of Mr. Blair then appears, with him being patted on the back by George W. Bush. A nonchalant Mr. Blair comments, "A day like today, I mean, it's not a day for sound-bites, really... um, we can leave those at home, I feel that, I feel the hand of history upon our shoulders..."

We then return to the Conservatives' montage, with extremely large lettering declaring, "IMAGINE ANOTHER 5 YEARS OF HIM.", with Mr. Blair commenting, "I feel the hand of history upon our shoulders." Some Conservative announcer then repeats the phrase, "Imagine another 5 years of him."

Are you thinking what I'm thinking?"Are you thinking what we're thinking?", is then displayed, with "VOTE CONSERVATIVE" appearing soon after. Throughout this final montage, Mr. Blair describes, "Enough of talking... it is time now to do... Thank you." End of advertisement.

The Music

The most noticeable part of the advertisement is the catchy tune. "Take That Look Off Your Face" is the tune played throughout the 90 seconds. It's quite a nice song, and it's an Andrew Lloyd Webber piece! Gotta love those showtunes.

Take that look off your face...
Take that look off your face...
I can see through your smile...
I can see through your smile...
You would love to be right.
I bet you... didn't sleep good last night,
Couldn't wait... to bring all of that bad news to my door.
Well, I've got news for you:
...
I knew before.

You knew before? You knew what before? You knew what before when? So many questions, so few showtunes. Even so, it's a catchy song.

The Impression

Is this ad effective? I'm uncertain. I guess that it does hit the point home -- if you don't trust Mr. Blair, why would you vote for (nominally) five more years of him?

But as I left the movie theatre, I left with a queasy feeling -- and it wasn't from Miss Congeniality 2. While the Tories are explicitly attacking Labour's performance over the past two terms, they're implicity attacking Mr. Blair's "trust" factor. Which is fair enough -- polls consistently show that Mr. Blair is one of the least trusted politicians in Britain.

But it's more than just a "trust" issue. While I adore Andrew Lloyd Webber, and while the tune is certainly catchy, I can't help but think that the Tories are criticizing Mr. Blair because he smiles/grins too much. Exactly why should we "take that look" off Mr. Blair's face?

Are we really voting against Blair 'cause we don't like his smile? How tacky is that? And isn't that just a little insensitive? Hell, many people smile and grin when they're placed in nervous, uncomfortable situations, too -- does that automatically preclude them from being PM?

How much different is this ad from the 1993 Chrétien ad in Canada? Sure, Mr. Blair's smiling isn't a physical deformity such as Mr. Chrétien's, but does that make him unfit to be PM?

Overall grade: B. The ad is a memorable one, thanks to the catchy showtune. I thought more about the ad than I did about Sandra Bullock, which is an obvious negative. But I can't help but feeling unclean after watching this spot. The UK Conservative political party is notorious (rightly or wrongly) for being "insensitive" to the makeup of British society. Now they're implying that Mr. Blair may not have the proper "face" to be PM. I find that to be terribly shallow.

The advertisement, the grins, and the smirks are courtesy conservatives.com .

Archive URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/archives/individual/2005/04/20/poon_more_election_videos_deconstructed_356.html

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/327