December 31, 2005
Jack Layton: Untrustworthy
I have long considered the N.D.P. to be a party of integrity. Even though they often unrealistic policy positions and show a disregard for economics sometimes, I believe that they do so with good intentions and not in any way to mislead. Although I preferred to see Bill Blakie win the 2003 leadership race, I thought that Jack Layton would continue in the honourable tradition of N.D.P. leaders. I even briefly considered voting for the N.D.P. last election.
Jack Layton however has shown that he's not like his predecessors: he's actually a run-of-the-mill unprincipled politician who's more interested in power than sticking to principle. Setting aside his flip-flops on such issues as the Clarity Act, consider his promise of how he'd use his influence in a minority.
Last election, Layton promised that he would use his influence in a minority to ensure a referendum on proportional representation. Nothing less would earn the N.D.P.'s backing for the government.
In April 2005, Jack Layton had his chance. The Liberals needed him to save their government. Jack Layton was saying that they needed to be held to account. Layton could have demanded that his price for protecting the Liberals from immediate accounting was for them to have a referendum on instituting a new, more accountable electoral system. But Jack Layton didn't. Instead, he asked for money. Jack Layton broke his election promise. Jack Layton refused to hold the government to account. He sold his principled stand for accountable government for some cold, hard cash. Just like the Liberals, Jack Layton showed that he'll give away accountable government for some money.
Of course, no sooner had Paul Martin escaped his reckoning, he made sure that Jack Layton never got the money for his part of the deal.
In November 2005, Jack Layton got the chance to redeem himself. The Conservatives and Bloc Quebecois were shaming Jack Layton into standing up for accountability. Once again, Jack Layton refused to stand for accountable government. And once again, he refused to make a referendum on proportional representation his prince for supporting the Liberals (he asked for some changes to health care policy, instead).
Today, Jack Layton is once again saying that proportional representation is his price for supporting a minority government.
Talk is cheap. Action counts. Paul Martin is a prime example of this: he talks a lot about protecting health care, dealing with homelessness and poverty, etc. but his actions show otherwise. Jack Layton's talk, however, does not match his actions.
Jack Layton has had not one, but two chances to show that he'll uphold his election promises. He's failed twice. Jack Layton has had two chances to show that he'll put accountable government first. He's failed twice. I don't think he deserves a third chance.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/449
December 24, 2005
As visions of sugar plums danced in their heads
Happy Christmas, Mr. Speaker! As the Canadian federal election campaign goes on its holiday hiatus, it's time to wish everyone a safe and happy holiday season.
And, just in case you're missing the elections hulabaloo during the break, you can vote on Christmas Day! Your friendly neighbourhood Elections Canada Returning Office will be open on the 25th to help us pursue the democratic process. What a great country, eh?
Our federal party leaders would also like to send their Christmas wishes:
Prime Minster Martin sends his holiday greetings through liberal.ca and www.pm.gc.ca. And, his annual Christmas card shows a fairly nice photo of Paul, Sheila, and sons Paul Jr. and David.
In his holiday greeting, Mr. Martin notes that "Each of us is reminded, in our own way - as we gather with friends and family- of the blessings that are given to us here in Canada."
The Canadian Press notes that Prime Minister Martin's dream Christmas gift is a screaming, bouncing grandchild. Well, maybe next year, Mr. Martin.
Stephen Harper's Christmas card is a little more cluttered, but there are some nice images of Laureen, Ben, and Rachel. It wins POI's "Cutest Political Xmas Card" award for 2005.
"As our family celebrates the Season, we give thanks
for the love of family, the joy of good friends, and for each and every blessing." When asked about his Christmas wishes, Mr. Harper also made the pithy "more time with my family" comment. But, when pressed, he was the only party leader that publicly wanted consumer goods (hockey books and music for his iPod).
I was unable to find a Christmas Card for Jim Harris. Even so, the Green Party offers Mr. Harris' Christmas wishes. "A wise man once said, 'We make a living by what we get, we make a life by what we give.' Never is this more true than during this time of year. As Canadians we are incredibly lucky to be where we are, even when the weather is just a little colder."
Well said. But, do you really think that Sir Winston S. Churchill was talking about Canadians, winter, or the Green Party?
Gilles Duceppe has no official Christmas card. Bah, humbug. However, the Bloc Québecois has some great Christmas multimedia on their website. There's a one-minute video commentary by Mr. Duceppe, with a nice Christmas tree in the background.
In his Christmas statement, Mr. Duceppe remarks, "Nous avons rappellé la population que si nous sommes en campagne électorale, c'est que le Parti Libéral a perdu la nécessaire autorité morale pour gouverner... le 23 janvier, on se soit fait notre véritable cadeau de Nöel, c’est à dire le plus de députés du Bloc possible pour réprésenter le Québec... Merci et joyeuses fêtes.” Huh.
But the Bloc has some great electronic Xmas cards, including “Heureusement, maintenant c’est Nöel", with a big fat Christmas present with a Bloc Québecois tag. Cute.
As for what he wants for Christmas, "Mr. Duceppe never makes lists of presents he wants or makes specific demands," Duceppe aide Karine Sauve said in an e-mail to the Canadian Press. Yah, tell that to the people of Québec. Merry Christmas all the same.
And, Jack Layton's Christmas card offers a nice black-and-white portrait of Jack, Olivia, and children Mike and Sarah. There's also a nice photo of Parliament Hill on the cover. Mr. Layton has simple Christmas wishes (more time with his family, more NDP caucus members), but he does show the most holiday spirit with a rousing rendition of Jingle Bells on his guitar.
Have a great holiday season, everyone.
(Files and photos were obtained through liberal.ca, conservative.ca, green.ca, bloc.org, politicswatch.com, the Canadian Press, and the Halifax Chronicle Herald.)
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/448
December 19, 2005
Oh, that Rob Anders. He's such a cad.
Madam Speaker, I have but one question for the Prime Minister: "Do you support homosexual sex marriage?".
I ask this, in contrast to the Prime Minister's known support for "heterosexual sex marriage", "homosexual marriages where the frustrated partners don't ever get it on", and "homosexual sex one night stands".
The Commons has the right to know, Madam Speaker, what is the government's stance on this phenomenon?
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/447
December 14, 2005
Harper and Layton on Martin's Anti-U.S. Grandstanding
Stephen Harper and Jack Layton give Paul Martin a smacking for his recent comment about the U.S.:
First, Stephen Harper:
I always remember when you had the kid who was always name-calling from a safe distance. There really wasn't much risk of a fight, and Mr. Martin reminds me of that kid.Mr. Martin. He's the kid name-calling from a safe distance. He couldn't throw a punch to save his llfe.
And, even better, Jack Layton:
The fact is, he's electioneering.He'll say anything to get elected. And whipping up the rhetoric against George Bush is very easy to do. The problem is, he hasn't delivered the goods.
He thinks he can stand up and wag his finger at George Bush and somehow impress somebody, It's time he started delivering results. That would allow Canadians to be able to speak to the world.
Canadians have known that the Liberals will say anything in an election to get elected. I think now the ambassador has discovered the same thing.
Ouch!
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/446
December 12, 2005
Sheer Brilliance from Paul Wells
I think that I think that this may be the greatest article on Canadian politics ever written.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/445
December 11, 2005
Campaign Propaganda
A couple of quick points:
First, the N.D.P. do the best job of pointing out how the Liberals are using party insiders in their ads. Though, to be fair, they are getting a hard ride out of this when every party uses actors or party activists in their ads.
And second, the Bloc Québécois shows once again why they are the best at pointing out the faults of the Liberal Party of Canada.
I will hopefully post something substantive in the next few days. Definately once exams are done next week, I'll be blogging about the election in full force.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/444
December 05, 2005
Good grief!
Steve Nease of The Oakville Beaver brings us the funniest political cartoon of the election:
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/443
December 04, 2005
Liberal Scott Reid's Comment
Noise from the Right claims that Liberal operative Scott Reid told the Calgary Herald's Don Martin that Alberta can blow me
.
Now, this has come from only one sources and a partisan one at that, so there may be more to this than has been reported. However, for those who ask why the Liberals cannot undo Western Alientation, I serve this as part of the problem.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.pointsofinformation.ca/poi-ping.cgi/442





